Brant Point and Wauwinet luxury neighborhood comparison

Brant Point vs Wauwinet

Nantucket Neighborhood Comparison

Overview

Harbor Prestige vs Ultimate Seclusion

Brant Point and Wauwinet represent the pinnacle of Nantucket luxury real estate. Brant Point offers prestigious harbor-front living just steps from downtown, while Wauwinet provides the ultimate in privacy and exclusivity at the island's northeastern tip.

Both neighborhoods command premium prices and attract discerning buyers seeking exceptional properties. The choice often comes down to whether you prefer the convenience of Brant Point or the seclusion of Wauwinet.

Market Data

Price Comparison

Brant Point lighthouse with harbor views and luxury waterfront estates
Brant Point
Median Home Price$8.5M
Available Properties8
Population150
RegionEast End
Wauwinet waterfront estates with harbor and ocean views
Wauwinet
Median Home Price$12.0M
Available Properties5
Population100
RegionEast End

Lifestyle

What to Expect

Brant Point

  • Walking distance to downtown
  • Iconic Brant Point Lighthouse views
  • White Elephant Resort proximity
  • Private docks and harbor access
  • Best views of Figawi Race and fireworks

Wauwinet

  • Maximum privacy and seclusion
  • Dual beach access (bay and ocean)
  • Wauwinet Inn luxury resort
  • Great Point Wildlife Sanctuary nearby
  • Grand estates with extensive grounds

Analysis

Pros & Cons

Brant Point

Advantages

  • Walking distance to everything
  • Iconic lighthouse location
  • Private dock opportunities
  • Strong resale value
  • Year-round convenience

Considerations

  • Highest prices on island
  • Limited inventory
  • Some tourist traffic
  • Smaller lot sizes
  • Harbor views vs ocean views

Wauwinet

Advantages

  • Ultimate privacy
  • Both bay and ocean access
  • Largest lot sizes on island
  • World-class resort amenities
  • Wildlife and nature

Considerations

  • Most expensive properties
  • Remote location
  • Limited year-round services
  • Requires transportation
  • Very limited inventory

Best Fit

Who Should Choose Each?

Brant Point is ideal for:

  • Buyers wanting luxury with convenience
  • Boating enthusiasts needing dock access
  • Those who value walkability
  • Event hosts and entertainers
  • Year-round luxury residents

Wauwinet is ideal for:

  • Ultra-high-net-worth buyers
  • Those seeking maximum privacy
  • Nature and wildlife enthusiasts
  • Buyers wanting compound potential
  • Those who prioritize seclusion over convenience

Common Questions

Brant Point vs Wauwinet

01

What's the price difference between Brant Point and Wauwinet?

Wauwinet typically has the highest median prices on Nantucket at around $12M, while Brant Point averages around $8.5M. Both represent the ultra-luxury end of the market with limited inventory.

02

Which neighborhood is better for boating?

Brant Point is better for boating due to its harbor location and private dock opportunities. Wauwinet offers bay access but is more focused on beach activities than active boating.

03

Can you walk to town from both neighborhoods?

Brant Point is walking distance to downtown, just about a mile to Main Street. Wauwinet is at the far eastern tip of the island and requires transportation to reach downtown.

04

Which has better beach access?

Wauwinet offers unique dual beach access to both Nantucket Bay (calm waters) and the Atlantic Ocean. Brant Point is near Jetties Beach and the harbor, but doesn't have the same oceanfront beach access.

05

Are there any resorts or restaurants in these neighborhoods?

Yes, both have prestigious resort properties. Brant Point is home to the White Elephant Resort and Brant Point Grill. Wauwinet features the historic Wauwinet Inn, a luxury oceanfront resort with fine dining.

Explore Further

View Individual Neighborhoods

Ready to Decide?

Let's Find Your Perfect Neighborhood