Overview
Surfside and Cisco are both beloved beach communities on Nantucket's south shore, attracting buyers who prioritize ocean access and a laid-back lifestyle. While they share similar beach vibes, each neighborhood has its own distinct personality and appeal.
Surfside is known for family-friendly activities and easy bike path access to downtown, while Cisco has become the heart of Nantucket's casual west end culture, anchored by the legendary Cisco Brewers complex.
Market Data
Lifestyle
Analysis
Best Fit
Common Questions
Both beaches offer excellent surfing conditions with consistent Atlantic swells. Cisco is slightly more renowned among serious surfers, while Surfside is popular for both surfing and boogie boarding with a more family-friendly atmosphere.
Both neighborhoods offer more affordable options than downtown or waterfront areas. Cisco tends to be slightly less expensive with a median around $2M, while Surfside averages around $2.2M, though specific prices vary greatly by property.
Cisco Brewers operates year-round but with reduced hours in the off-season. Summer is peak season with daily live music, food trucks, and a vibrant outdoor beer garden atmosphere.
Surfside has better access to downtown via its dedicated bike path, making it possible to bike directly from Surfside Beach to downtown Nantucket. Cisco requires a car or the WAVE shuttle for most trips.
Yes, both are family-friendly. Surfside is particularly popular with families due to its wide beach, lifeguards, and BBQ areas. Cisco appeals to families who enjoy the brewery culture (with kid-friendly outdoor spaces) and proximity to Bartlett's Farm.