SPRING MARKET SNAPSHOT
Spring 2025: Market Momentum Continues
As spring 2025 settles over Nantucket, the luxury real estate market remains strong—drawing second-home buyers, investors, and lifestyle-driven homeowners. With average sale prices reaching $3.8 million in April, representing a strong first half performance, the market reflects sustained demand and limited inventory on this exclusive island.
Spring brings an infusion of new listings as sellers position their homes for peak summer interest, giving early buyers first pick of premium inventory before competitive multiple-offer scenarios dominate the market.
Spring 2025 Price Trajectory
Average sale prices showing April peak of $3.8 million
Many sellers list in April and May to position their homes for peak summer interest, giving early buyers first pick of new inventory before multiple-offer scenarios become the norm in July and August.
MARKET DYNAMICS
Q2 2025 Market Performance
Inventory Infusion
Tight Inventory: Active listings declined 22% year-over-year to 185 properties by September—maintaining a strong seller's market on the island
Active Listings: 175 properties by end of June, down from 200 in January—reflecting limited supply on this exclusive island
Hottest Price Point: Properties in the $2M–$4M range dominate buyer activity, with median sale price at $2.5M for H1 2025
Price Range: Single-family home sales range from $400,000 to $42 million+, with average sale price around $3.74 million
Spring Buyer Profile
Affluent Second-Home Buyers: From Greater Boston, Westchester County, NYC, and increasingly from Texas & California
Pre-Retirement Couples: Individuals in their late 50s and early 60s securing long-term waterfront residences before retirement
Remote Professionals: High-net-worth individuals leveraging flexible work arrangements for year-round coastal living
Lifestyle Investors: Buyers recognizing short-term rental potential and long-term appreciation in exclusive enclaves
Quarterly Sales Volume
Transaction activity showing strong Q2 spring performance with 73 sales
REGIONAL ANALYSIS
Premier Nantucket Communities
Average Sale Price by Community
Top-performing luxury markets on Nantucket (Spring 2025)
Brant Point
The most exclusive waterfront enclave on Nantucket. Beloved for its proximity to downtown, harbor views, and historic charm. Spring inventory includes premium waterfront properties, with top sales reaching $7.8M+ this quarter.
Highest property values on the island
Sconset
A hub of high-net-worth activity with oceanfront bluffs, historic rose-covered cottages, and proximity to Sankaty Head Golf Club. Waterfront and bluff-top homes consistently command top market prices.
Historic charm & oceanfront prestige
Downtown
Highly sought after for walkability and vibrant village life. Buyers seek historic homes with panoramic harbor views and proximity to Main Street shops and restaurants. The heart of Nantucket's cultural scene.
Premium for walkability & village charm
Surfside
Continues to attract families, investors, and luxury buyers valuing beach access, ocean views, and proximity to Surfside Beach. Oceanfront and near-beach homes are especially desirable for summer living.
Beach access & family-friendly appeal
INVENTORY TRENDS
Spring Listing Activity
Monthly Inventory Growth
New spring listings providing more buyer options
With inventory declining from 200 listings in January to 175 by June, spring 2025 reflects the tight supply characteristic of Nantucket's exclusive market, maintaining strong seller leverage throughout the season.
EMERGING TRENDS
What Spring 2025 Reveals About Buyer Priorities
Homes Designed for Wellness
Properties with dedicated fitness rooms, plunge pools, spa-like bathrooms, and saunas command premium pricing. Buyers prioritize health-centric amenities.
Energy-Conscious Buyers
Growing interest in solar panels, battery storage, EV charging, and energy-efficient systems. Sustainable features are no longer optional—they're expected.
Walkability & Access
Homes near downtown villages, marinas, and beaches are outpacing market averages in appreciation. Convenience & lifestyle trump pure waterfront premium.
Multi-Generational Living
Properties with guest houses, carriage houses, or ADUs offer flexibility for family gatherings. This trend is reshaping buyer priorities across all price points.
STRATEGIC TIMING
Why Spring 2025 is a Smart Time to Buy
First Pick of Inventory
Many sellers list in April-May to position homes for summer interest. Early buyers get first access before July-August competition.
Rental ROI Opportunity
Acquiring before peak season allows owners to secure summer rental income, offsetting 30-40% of annual carrying costs.
Negotiation Leverage
Competition intensifies in June-July. Spring buyers may have more room to negotiate before multiple-offer scenarios become standard.
The fundamentals remain strong: limited high-end inventory, consistent buyer demand from affluent second-home seekers, and the unmatched coastal lifestyle that makes Nantucket so much more than just a seasonal destination.
Contact Us
Get In Touch
Whether you're buying, selling, or exploring Nantucket real estate opportunities, we're here to help.