PEAK SEASON SNAPSHOT
Summer 2025: A Seller's Market at Its Peak
Summer 2025 has delivered exceptional results for Nantucket's luxury real estate market. Peak season has brought a surge in buyer activity, particularly among affluent second-home seekers and premium waterfront property investors.
With September posting the fifth-highest dollar volume month ever recorded at $284 million, and competing offers becoming the norm, premium waterfront properties are commanding unprecedented prices. The summer months have reinforced Nantucket's position as the premier island destination for luxury real estate.
Summer 2025 Price Trajectory
Average sale prices throughout peak season showing September median of $4.67M
September 2025 posted the fifth-highest dollar volume month ever recorded in Nantucket history at $284 million, with 62 transactions. Premium waterfront properties often receive multiple offers within hours of listing during peak summer months.
Waterfront Premier
Waterfront Properties Command Premium
Waterfront Premium Analysis
Average sale prices by property type showing substantial waterfront markup
Oceanfront Dominance
Highest Transaction Values: Direct oceanfront homes with panoramic views consistently exceed $3M+ in prime locations like Brant Point, Sconset, and Surfside
Days on Market: Premium oceanfront homes average 127 days YTD, with many selling quickly during peak summer months
Competition: Multiple offer situations are standard, with September posting record-breaking $284M in transactions
Price Range: Waterfront properties command significant premiums, with sales ranging from $400K to $42M+ on the island
Seasonal Premiums
Growing Demand: Harbor and bay properties offer exceptional value with comparable lifestyle at 10-20% lower prices than oceanfront
Harbor Access: Properties with direct harbor or mooring access are premium in Downtown, Brant Point, and Madaket
Beach Access: Homes with formal beach access or proximity to Surfside Beach command 15-25% premium over non-waterfront comparables
Seasonal Rental Potential: Waterfront properties generate $3,200-$7,500+ per week during peak summer season
MARKET ACTIVITY
Peak Season Transaction Volume
Monthly Sales Activity
Transaction volume throughout summer showing September peak of 62 sales
BUYER INSIGHTS
Who's Buying This Summer
Affluent Second-Home Buyers
From Boston, New York, and increasingly from Texas and California, these buyers prioritize turnkey, low-maintenance properties with proximity to water and vibrant town centers.
- ✓ Seeking immediate occupancy
- ✓ Focus on lifestyle amenities
- ✓ Price flexibility for premium locations
Lifestyle Investors
High-net-worth individuals recognizing short-term rental potential and long-term appreciation. Summer purchases position them for immediate booking season revenue.
- ✓ Calculating rental ROI
- ✓ Long-term appreciation focus
- ✓ Premium location priorities
Pre-Retirement Couples
Individuals in their late 50s and early 60s securing long-term residences that transition from vacation homes to primary residences. Summer climate appeals to this demographic.
- ✓ Permanence planning
- ✓ Community integration
- ✓ Quality of life prioritization
Remote Professionals
Wealthy work-flexible individuals extending summer coastal stays into semi-permanent arrangements. The pandemic accelerated this demographic's Nantucket real estate activity.
- ✓ Flexible timelines
- ✓ Home office requirements
- ✓ Coastal lifestyle priority
SUMMER HOTSPOTS
Most Active Summer Markets
Downtown
Peak summer activity centers on Main Street, harbor views, and the walkable village. Summer crowds drive rental demand to premium pricing for historic homes.
Highest summer transaction volume
Brant Point
Summer brings peak yachting and harbor activity. Waterfront properties with harbor views attract high-end buyers seeking exclusive island lifestyle.
Premium waterfront prestige
Sconset
Bluff-top homes with ocean views and historic rose-covered cottages represent the quieter side of summer Nantucket—premium for those seeking privacy and charm.
Historic charm & oceanfront appeal
Surfside
Beachfront and near-beach properties reach peak demand during summer as families seek direct beach access and ocean views in this family-friendly area.
Beach access & family appeal
Cisco & Polpis
Expansive properties with privacy and natural beauty attract buyers seeking larger lots and seclusion. These areas offer exceptional value for luxury estate properties.
Privacy & natural beauty
Madaket
West-end properties with sunset views and proximity to Madaket Beach attract buyers seeking the quieter side of the island with stunning natural beauty.
Sunset views & west-end charm
INVESTMENT ANALYSIS
Summer Rental Income Potential
Peak Season Weekly Rental Rates
Average weekly rental income for luxury waterfront properties
A luxury waterfront property generating $6,000/week during peak summer season can produce $50,000-$75,000 in annual rental income, offsetting 30-40% of annual carrying costs for high-net-worth owners.
2025 SUMMER TRENDS
What Summer 2025 Reveals About Buyer Priorities
Wellness Integration
Buyers prioritize homes with pool houses, outdoor spas, and ocean access—supporting summer wellness and entertaining. Health-focused design commands premiums.
Smart Home Technology
Smart climate control, pool automation, and security systems are now expected standard in luxury properties, enabling remote property management while away.
Sustainable Luxury
EV charging, solar arrays, and energy-efficient systems appeal to affluent buyers seeking to minimize environmental impact while maintaining luxury amenities.
Multi-Generational Planning
Summer property acquisitions increasingly accommodate extended family gatherings. Guest houses and ADUs attract multi-generational buyers planning legacy properties.
Contact Us
Get In Touch
Whether you're buying, selling, or exploring Nantucket real estate opportunities, we're here to help.